Best
Compliance (A+)
Flight (A+)
Life of Pi (A+)
Breathless (A+)
Django Unchained (A+)
The Cabin in the Woods (A+)
Zero Dark Thirty (A-)
Marvel's The Avengers (A-)
Lincoln (A-)
Wreck-it Ralph (A-)
Worst
Paranormal Activity IV (F)
Alex Cross (D-)
The Cold Light of Day (D-)
Chernobyl Diaries (D-)
The Devil Inside (D-)
The Amazing Spider-man (D-)
Total Recall (D+)
Step Up Revolution (D+)
Stolen (D+)
The Possession (D+)
2011
Best
30 Minutes or Less (B+)
Horrible Bosses (B+)
The Debt (B+)
Melancholia (B+)
Paul (A-)
Limitless (A-)
Kung Fu Panda II (A-)
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (A-)
Source Code (A-)
Our Idiot Brother (A+)
Jane Eyre (A+)
Hugo (A+)
The Descendants (A+)
Bridesmaids (A+)
A Separation (A+)
Worst
Immortals (D+)
Conan the Barbarian (D+)
Apollo 18 (D+)
Transformers: Dark of the Moon (D+)
Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D (D+)
Sucker Punch (D+)
Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked (D-)
The Roommate (D-)
Dream House (D-)
Season of the Witch (D-)
Priest (D-)
Jack and Jill (D-)
The Human Centipede II (Full Sequence) (F)
Red Riding Hood (F)
Beastly (F)
2010
Best
Despicable Me (A-)
Easy A (A+)
How to Train Your Dragon (A+)
Iron Man 2 (A-)
Machete (A+)
Splice (A-)
The American (A-)
The Fighter (A+)
The King's Speech (A+)
The Town (A+)
Worst
Furry Vengeance (F)
Grown Ups (D-)
Jonah Hex (D-)
Legion (F)
Repo Men (D-)
Skyline (D-)
The Back-up Plan (F)
The Last Airbender (F)
The Spy Next Door (D-)
The Warrior's Way (F)
2009
Best
Precious: Based on the Novel "Push" by Sapphire (A+)
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs (B+)
Avatar (A-)
The Invention of Lying (A-)
I Love You, Man (A-)
Watchmen (A+)
Zombieland (A-)
Up (A+)
Worst
All About Steve (D-)
Dragonball: Evolution (F)
Gamer (F)
G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra (F)
Knowing (D-)
Land of the Lost (D-)
Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen (F)
The Unborn (D-)
Whiteout (D-)
2008
Best
Frost/Nixon (A+)
The Wrestler (A+)
Kung Fu Panda (A+)
Bolt (A-)
Wall-E (A+)
Worst
Transporter 3 (F)
Babylon A.D. (F)
Disaster Movie (F)
Nights in Rodanthe (D-)
The Happening (F)
2007
Best
Breach (A+)
3:10 to Yuma (A+)
There Will Be Blood (A-)
Worst
Delta Farce (F)
Daddy Day Camp (F)
Transformers (F)
2006
Best
United 93 (A+)
Children of Men (A+)
Borat (A+)
The Departed (A+)
Worst
Basic Instinct 2 (D-)
Date Movie (F)
Sea of Fear (F)
2005
Best
Sin City (A+)
V for Vendetta (A+)
Kung Fu Hustle (A+)
The 40-Year-Old Virgin (A+)
Worst
Alone in the Dark (F)
Domino (D-)
Son of the Mask (D-)
White Noise (D-)
2004
Best
Kill Bill, Vol. 2 (A-)
Saw (A+)
Troy (B+)
Crash (A+)
Million Dollar Baby (A+)
Worst
Alexander (D-)
Resident Evil: Apocalypse (F)
Catwoman (D-)
House of the Dead (F)
Flight of the Phoenix (D-)
2003
Best
21 Grams (A+)
Big Fish (A+)
Kill Bill Vol. 1 (A+)
28 Days Later (A+)
Finding Nemo (A+)
The Magdalene Sisters (B+)
Seabiscuit (A+)
Worst
The Cat in the Hat (F)
Gigli (F)
2002
Best
Spider-man (A+)
Analyze That (B+)
One Hour Photo (B+)
The Bourne Identity (A+)
Worst
Feardotcom (F)
Signs (D-)
2001
Best
A Beautiful Mind (A-)
Momento (A+)
Down to Earth (B+)
Worst
The Mummy Returns (D-)
Freddie Got Fingered (F)
2000
Best
Cast Away (A-)
Erin Brockovich (A+)
X-Men (A-)Gladiator (A+)
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon (A+)
Worst
The Cell (D-)
Battlefield Earth (F)
Mission to Mars (F)
1999
Best
American Beauty (A+)
Girl, Interrupted (A+)
The Matrix (A+)
The Sixth Sense (A+)
Fight Club (A+)
Iron Giant (A+)
The Blair Witch Project (A+)
Man on the Moon (A-)
The Thomas Crown Affair (A-)
Worst
Baby Geniuses (F)
The Omega Code (F)
The Haunting (F)
The Ninth Gate (D-)
The Out-of-Towners (D+)
1998
Best
As Good as it Gets (A+)
The Negotiator (A+)
Pleasantville (A-)
Worst
Replacement Killers (D-)
Hard Rain (D+)
Beloved (D-)
1997
Best
Absolute Power (A-)
Princess Mononoke (A-)
The Game (A+)
Good Will Hunting (A+)
The Apostle (A+)
Titanic (A+)
Starship Troopers (A+)
Wag the Dog (A+)
G.I. Jane (A+)
Worst
Batman and Robin (F)
Speed 2: Cruise Control (F)
1996
Best
The English Patient (A+)
Sling Blade (A+)
Ransom (A+)
Primal Fear (A+)
Rumble in the Bronx (A-)
The Rock (A-)
Worst
The Cable Guy (D+)
Striptease (D+)
Black Sheep (D+)
Mad Dog Time (F)
Lake Placid (D-)
Wild Wild West (F)
1995
Best
Braveheart (A-)
Casino (A+)
Dead Man Walking (A+)
The American President (A-)
Se7en (A+)
Tommy Boy (A-)
Worst
Showgirls (D-)
1994
Best
Speed (A-)
Forest Gump (A+)
The Shawshank Redemption (A+)
Worst
Even Cowboys Get the Blues (F)
North (F)
1993
Best
In the Line of Fire (A+)
What's eating Gilbert Grape? (A+)
Groundhog Day (A+)
Falling Down (A-)
The Firm (A+)
Worst
Super Mario Brothers (F)
Robin Hood: Men in Tights (F)
1992
Best
Unforgiven (A+)
Basic Instinct (A-)
A Few Good Men (A+)
Worst
Unlawful Entry (D+)
Passenger 57 (D+)
1991
Best
Terminator 2: Judgment Day (A+)
Thelma and Louise (A+)
Boyz N the Hood (A+)
The Silence of the Lambs (A+)
Worst
Robin Hood: Price of Thieves (D+)
Hudson Hawk (D+)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (D-)
Highlander 2: The Quickening (D-)
1990
Best
Jacob's Ladder (A+)
The Abyss (A-)
Dead Poets Society (A+)
Uncle Buck (A+)
Goodfellas (A+)
Worst
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (D+)
Look Who's Talking Too (D-)